Tuesday, May 13, 2008

Clinics, Labs, Centers

The name has changed but the issues of clientelle, staffing, and institutional identity are still at the forefront of discussion: how to break free of the remedial stigma, who is qualified to tutor and what kind of training is needed, and how all this affects the institution's identity. All provide a place where discussion of writing took/takes place. Summerfield equates writing cernters with workshops that recognize "the social nature of language and learning. A genuine workshop is one that builds a community of writers, readers, listeners, talkers, thinkers, who are encouraged to understand how they write as individuals, but equally important, as members of a community" (25). While I would not visit a writing center for help in conventions, I would relish having a community of writers to discuss my and their ideas. Professionally, writers' groups perform the same service as writing centers but few visualize writing centers in this way. I wonder if administrators, teachers, and students will ever be able to truly view writing centers as communities of writers.

2 comments:

jrgm said...

Wasn't Summerfield saying that her administrators did see it as a community and that is why it dropped funding and booted her out? She argued that the admins didn't want the power that comes in numbers, right?

Karen Neubauer said...

I think Summerfield was talking about the admin looking at the writing center community as dangerous -- although that still sounds a little 60ish The-Man-is-Holdin'-Me-Back to me. But I am interested in the idea of building a writing community around the WC. That's how I describe my classroom to my students and I think it would be great to build that same atmosphere around the WC -- one that transcends semesters.